We”ll continue the “Best of” series of polls with your selection as the best third baseman in the system. This should be a more interesting vote. There is no Hoskins, Kingery, or Crawford to monopolize votes. Not having a clear cut, top prospect is a little worrisome with Maikel Franco’s struggles this season. I hate to pin our hopes on a trade that is unlikely to happen or the the free agent class after the 2018 season. Continue reading 2017 Phuture Phillies Top Third Baseman Poll
Results of 2017 Phuture Phillies Top Shortstop Poll
The outcome for the Best Shortstop Poll was predictable. J.P. Crawford garnered almost half the votes. Crawford got off to a slow start this season but he rebounded from his long, early slump and posted a full season slash of .243/.351/.405/.756 with 15 HR and 63 RBI in 556 plate appearances. He walked 79 times and struck out 97 times. His recovery was so good that he earned a September to the Phillies where he has played very well. The career shortstop has been playing almost exclusively at second and third the past month. Continue reading Results of 2017 Phuture Phillies Top Shortstop Poll
Open Discussion: Week of September 24th
This week the Phillies posted a 4-3 record. They came within a Pinto of sweeping a four-game series from the Los Angeles Dodgers. They had a 4-3 lead in the fourth game when Mark Leiter turned the game over to the bullpen. Leiter had held the Dodgers to just one earned run in his six innings. The Phillies then dropped two out of three to the Atlanta Braves. They have a 62-94 record and a .397 PCT. They are still not the worst team in baseball. Continue reading Open Discussion: Week of September 24th
Results of 2017 Phuture Phillies Top Second Baseman Poll
The outcome for the Best Second Baseman Poll was predictable. Scott Kingery was the runaway winner. Kingery was the winner of the Paul Owens Award for the top hitter in their minor league system. He also won the Rawlings Gold Glove Award for Second Base from among all second basemen in the minor leagues. Kingery split time between Reading and Lehigh Valley and posted a combined .304/.359/.530/.889 with 26 HR and 65 RBI in 603 plate appearances. He struck out 109 times (18.1%) and walked 41 times (6.8%). His numbers were considerably better at AA. Continue reading Results of 2017 Phuture Phillies Top Second Baseman Poll
2017 Phuture Phillies Top Shortstop Poll
We”ll continue the “Best of” series of polls with your selection as the best shortstop in the system. Again, I have allowed a maximum of three answers for each ballot. This will allow us to establish what kind of depth we have in the organization. This is repeat of the first two votes insofar as the eventual winner should win by a large margin and the more interesting discussion will be about the runners up. Continue reading 2017 Phuture Phillies Top Shortstop Poll
Results of 2017 Phuture Phillies Top First Baseman Poll
The outcome for the Best First Baseman Poll was predictable. Rhys Hoskins was the runaway winner. I know that there were some who didn’t think that he should be included in the poll. But, if Hoskins can be awarded the International League’s Rookie of the Year and Most Valuable Player then I wasn’t going to arbitrarily exclude him. This was an instance where voters could have overridden my decision, and didn’t. Continue reading Results of 2017 Phuture Phillies Top First Baseman Poll
2017 Phuture Phillies Top Second Baseman Poll
We”ll continue the “Best of” series of polls with your selection as the best second baseman in the system. Again, I have allowed a maximum of three answers for each ballot. This will allow us to establish what kind of depth we have in the organization. This is also handy for second base where I expect a land slide in favor of the top guy similar to the one we had for first base.
(Don’t forget to submit your top prospect list by e-mailing it to prospectpoll@yahoo.com. To date I have received only 18 lists, one as short as seven and a couple as long as fifty.)
Each player listed below is in the poll and played at least 10 games at the position. I have included a link to the player’s profile in Baseball Reference. And I have included a link to Gregg’s Report Card for Middle Infielders.
- Scott Kingery – real good seasons at AA and AAA, I became a believer during spring training
- Pedro Florimon – didn’t see enough of him last season
- Jesmuel Valentin – spent most of the season on the DL
- Angelo Mora – second is his best position, IMO
- Drew Stankiewicz – steady, versatile infielder
- Grenny Cumana – passable middle infield defense who can hit a little
- Jose Antequera – versatile infielder who didn’t hit well in 2017
- Derek Campbell – the injury really set him back, probably passed by younger guys
- Daniel Brito – a second base only guy whose hitting dropped off after the jump from the 2016 GCL
- Raul Rivas – didn’t see enough of him before he went to Williamsport
- Jake Scheiner – didn’t see enough of him before he went to Williamsport
- Brian Mims – didn’t see enough of him before he went to Williamsport
- Jesus Azuaje – didn’t see enough of him before he went to Williamsport
- Brayan Gonzalez – solid defensive infielder, showed some bat toward the end of the season
- Jesus Henriquez – versatile, multi-position player
Report Card–Outfield, CW, REA and LV
Lehigh Valley
Cam Perkins, 26, Phils 6th round pick in 2012; .288/.374/.447 in 257AB; 7HR 27RBI; 3SB; 10%BB/16%K; For Phils: .174/.232/.267 in 86AB; 61 games in the OF with 4 errors and 3 OF assists; 4 games at 1B without an error; Perkins continued to be a plus hitter and fielder at the AAA level but it did not translate to the majors in Perkins time with the big club this season. Perkins can be a competent #5 major league outfielder but I believe with the talent coming through the OF, he just as likely could be DFA’d in the offseason. Grade: B-
Roman Quinn, 24, Phils 2nd round pick in 2011; .274/.344/.389 in 175AB; 2HR 13RBI; 10SB; 9%BB/25%K; 44 games in the OF with 4 errors, 2 OF assists; I am at a loss for words on Quinn but Ill try. Another season cut significantly short by injury; When healthy (and that is almost never), he is a true talent. He hasn’t played a game since May. Grade: D-; 2018: Quinn is a guy the Phils are more than likely afraid to remove from the 40 because they will lose him because his upside is tremendous. He will likely stick around one more year to prove his health.
Andrew Pullin,23, Phils 5th round pick in 2012; .272/.327/.488 in 504AB; 20HR 69RBI; 5SB; 6%BB/17%K; For LV: .231/.280/.412 in 238AB; 6HR 23RBI; 20%K; 95 games in the OF with 3 errors, 2 OF assists; Pullin moved up to Lehigh Valley after raking for parts of the last two seasons in Reading and the AAA numbers were mediocre in the half season up with the ‘Pigs. Grade: B-; 2018: Pullin is Rule 5 eligible if not added to the 40. I don’t think he will be added, nor do I think he will be selected in the Rule 5. 2018: Lehigh Valley
Herlis Rodriguez, 23, Signed as a free agent in 2011; .249/.314/398 in 357AB between Clearwater, Reading and LV; 11HR 34RBI; 10SB; .216/.259/.318 in 148AB with LV; 3%BB/24%K; 77 games in the OF with 3 errors, 7 OF assists; 6 games at 1B without an error; Rodriguez played well at Clearwater but them slumped in Lehigh Valley. The Phils likely wanted to see Rodriguez get some significant playing time in against high level competition as unless he is added to the 40 man roster, he will become a minor league free agent. I think it very unlikely he is added to the 40 man. Grade: C
Dylan Cozens, 23, Phils 2nd round pick in 2012; .210/.301/.418 in 476AB; 27HR 75RBI; 8SB; 11%BB/36%K rates; .194 vs LHP; .217 vs RHP; .165 last 30 days; .151/.273/.283 Post All Star Game with a 44%K rate; 109 games in the OF with 4 errors and 9 OF assists; Regress is too diplomatic a term to describe what happened to Cozens during the second half of the season. The numbers are mind bogglingly (is that a word?) poor. His power potential and athleticism rank at the top of the Phils prospects but any semblance of long term success is a real question mark. Grade: D; 2018: Lehigh Valley
Carlos Tocci, 22, Signed as a free agent in 2011; .294/.346/.381 in 482AB; 3HR 52RBI; 4/9SB; 6%BB/15%K; For LV: Hit .189 in 53AB; 123 games in the OF with 2 errors; 8 OF assists; Tocci had an excellent season in Reading before struggling in the last month of the season for Lehigh Valley; Tocci will never hit for power but did a nice job hitting for average and knocked in 50+ with is a nice number for Tocci. His fielding remains outstanding. Grade: B+; 2018: I hope to see Tocci on the 40 man and in Lehigh Valley Continue reading Report Card–Outfield, CW, REA and LV
Report Card, Outfield–GCL, WIlliamsprt and Lakewood
Lakewood
Adam Haseley, 21, Phils 1st round pick in 2017; .284/.357/.405 between GCL, WP and Lakewood in 215AB; 3HR 28RBI; 6SB; 9%BB/18%K; Hit .258 for Lakewood in 18 games; 49 games in the OF with 1 error and 1 OF assist; Many expected Haseley to immediately start his career in Clearwater but it didn’t happen that way. He produced for both GCL and Williamsport as expected and was coming around for Lakewood at the end of a very long year for Haseley; Grade: B; 2018: CLearwater
Mickey Moniak, 19, Phils 1st round pick in 2016; .236/.284/.341 in 466AB; 5HR 44RBI; 11/18SB; 6%BB/23%K; .179 vs LHP; .255 vs RHP; .145 last 30 days; 115 games in the OF with 3 errors; 7 OF assists; The expectations for Moniak have to be weighed against expectations for the #1 overall pick in the draft (as he was), and with that said, it was a pretty ugly year. There were signs of his true talent which would appear and then disappear for prolonged periods. The “its a long season” adage was trumpeted by those in the organization over and over again in protecting Moniak, who was playing full season ball for the first time professionally. That said, he was held out of 30 games for a variety of reasons, including rest. Moniak hit just .201 after the all star break, striking out 24% of the time. His work against lefties was miserable. Lets hope the early season Moniak gets extended into July, August and further next season; Grade: D; 2018: Lakewood
David Martinelli, 22, Phils 6th round pick in 2016; .205/.258/.328 in 302AB; 6HR 26RBI; 4SB; 7%BB/28%K; .197 vs LHP; .207 vs RHP; .132 last 30 days; 90 games in the OF with 1 error; 5 OF assists; Little production from Martinelli who struggled equally against all forms of pitching. His high draft status may keep him around for one more year but he is on the fence. Grade: D Continue reading Report Card, Outfield–GCL, WIlliamsprt and Lakewood
2017 Phuture Phillies Top First Baseman Poll
We”ll start the “Best of” series of polls with your selection as the best first baseman in the system. I have allowed a maximum of three answers for each ballot. This will allow us to establish what kind of depth we have in the organization. This is especially handy for first base where I expect there to be a land slide in favor of the top guy.
(Don’t forget to submit your top prospect list by e-mailing it to prospectpoll@yahoo.com.)
Each player listed below is in the poll and played at least 10 games at the position. I have included a link to the player’s profile in Baseball Reference. And I have included a link to Gregg’s Report Card for Corner Infielders.
- Rhys Hoskins – what can I say, great season
- Brock Stassi – sentimental favorite, free agent
- Kyle Martin – big disappointment
- Harold Martinez – my first favorite player, changed the way I view prospects, always seemed more comfortable as a hitter when he played first base, free agent
- Damek Tomscha – looked good in Clearwater
- Zach Green – the injury really set him back, probably passed by younger guys
- Wilson Garcia – too small for the position, IMO
- Darick Hall – big spring, surprised it took so long for him to be moved up
- Austin Listi – didn’t see enough of him before he went to Williamsport
- Greg Pickett – promising, I liked him as an outfielder, leg injury probably prompted position change, big power bat
- Brian Mims – didn’t see enough of him before he went to Williamsport
- Quincy Nieporte – reminded me of Jake Fox before Fox became a GCL coach, would have rather seen him at a higher level
- Edwin Rodriguez – lost time at position to Pickett then Nieporte, probably doesn’t figure in Phillies’ plans