Exiting the excitement that surrounded draft week, now is as good as time as any to look at how the Phils Top 5 prospects have changed since the beginning of the season. This is how it goes now from my perspective.
1. JP Crawford–I had Crawford ranked second pre-season and his continued excellence has only increased enthusiasm. He should shortly be moving to Clearwater and remains on target to hit Philadelphia late in 2016.
2. Aaron Nola–With his college pedigree, Nola is as “cant miss” as you can get in the draft. He isn’t a can’t miss superstar, but as close to a can’t miss #2 or #3 starter as possible. Those kind of players are clearly at a premium in any organization, let alone the Phillies.
3. Maikel Franco–I am still very high on Franco, but this years early season struggles make it clear that he has a few glaring weaknesses that need continued work at the minor league level. I expect Franco to have a long and successful career in Philadelphia, just not as soon as originally expected. Franco drops from #1 to #3.
4. Jesse Biddle–I am ready to buy in to the question marks. I have seen Biddle live look simply awesome in his 15+K performance against Harrisburg last year and also seen him struggle mightily with his command, while becoming clearly flustered by the occasional lack of defense behind him. He has the talent of a #2 starter. It is up to Biddle and the Phils to continue to develop it. He has dropped from #3 to #4 in my book.
5. Kenny Giles–Just to the majors last week, Giles still qualifies as a prospect with just a third of an inning of major league experience. As I am not about to put the label of #5 prospect on Carlos Tocci, who, albeit at 18, still struggles to hit the ball out of the infield or Kelly Dugan, who has had a half season filled with injuries. So, it becomes Giles who after a difficult year last year became the talk of the town for the first two and a half months of the season. He was lights out in Reading and did a decent job in Lehigh Valley with some notable command issues. His upside is very high as back-end of the bullpen guy who will strike out a ton of hitters. From from a finished product, best case scenario would have had him in Lehigh Valley until September.
Looking forward to the discussion….