Reading Phillies Weekly Report (4/20 – 5/3)

I know this is a bit long, but it encompasses two weeks worth of action due to my critically ill daughter, oops, I meant computer.  No really, I did.  I hope everyone enjoys the goodness that Reading has to offer and comments it up.  Have fun!

Over the past two weeks, the Phillies have had some phenomenal individual efforts by the likes of Stutes, Worley, Bastardo, and Taylor.  Even with these efforts, however, the Phils found themselves only going 7-5 over that two week span.  Despite the mediocre record, I think the teams play thus far is above what most of us expected.  Surprisingly, the Phils sit at 13-8 and are tied for 3rd in the Eastern League.  Not surprisingly, the pitching has really carried the team while the offense has mostly been a one man show featuring Michael Taylor.

Standings

EAS Northern Division W L PCT GB STREAK L10
New Hampshire 13 9 .591 W1 5-5
Binghamton 11 9 .550 1.0 L1 5-5
Connecticut 11 11 .500 2.0 W1 6-4
New Britain 10 11 .476 2.5 W3 7-3
Portland 10 11 .476 2.5 L1 4-6
Trenton 9 11 .450 3.0 L4 3-7
EAS Southern Division W L PCT GB STREAK L10
Akron 18 4 .818 W5 8-2
Erie 13 8 .619 4.5 W2 7-3
Reading 13 8 .600 5.0 L3 5-5
Bowie 9 12 .429 8.5 L2 4-6
Altoona 6 16 .273 12.0 L2 3-7
Harrisburg 4 16 .200 13.0 W2 2-8

Game Recaps

04/20/09 – Reading Phillies () at Altoona Curve ()

Postponed due to rain.

04/21/09 – Reading Phillies (3) at Altoona Curve (1)

The Phils got the week started on a positive note, as Tyson Brummett and Antonio Bastardo combined to confuse the Curve hitters for 9 terrific innings.  Brummett started the game and lasted 7.2 innings allowing only 1 earned run on 5 hits and 0 walks.  Brummett also managed to strikeout 5 in what was Brummett’s best performance in a strong start to the season.  Brummett has now given up 17 hits/walks in 17.2 innings pitched.  This is a good start for Brummett who needs to put together a strong ’09 season.  Bastardo came on in relief of Brummett with two outs in the eighth inning, after Brummett had collected 2 quick outs.  An inspired Bastardo finished the game with 1.1 innings of 2 hit ball.  Fortunately for the Phils, they got tremendous pitching as their offense was kept mostly dormant for the game.  All 3 of Reading’s runs were produced by the 3-4-5 hitters as Taylor, Stavisky, and Mahar combined to go 4-9 with 2 walks.  Taylor scored 2 runs on 1 hit and 1 walk.  Harman went hitless in the 2-hole.

04/22/09 – Reading Phillies (4) at Altoona Curve (5)

Sadly, the best way to describe this game would be frustrating.  Savery started the game and turned in a mediocre performance.  He lasted 6 innings giving up 5 hits, 2 walks, and 1 home run which all culminated in 4 earned runs.  He also racked up 6 k’s.  Savery was relieved by Bisenius, who promptly allowed another earned run one 1 hit and 2 walks in his 1.2 innings of work.  Escalona recorded the final out in the eighth inning for the Phils.  Not to be outdone, the offense turned in their own mediocre performance.  Combined, the offense had 7 hits, 2 of which were doubles.  With the aid of 2 Altoona errors, the Phils managed to score 4 runs.  Taylor went hitless on the night.  Sadly, the Phil’s best hitter was in fact their pitcher.  Savery went 2-3 with 2 runs scored.  All in all, it was a rather mundane game with few matters of interest.  Moving on…

04/23/09 – Reading Phillies (7) vs. Bowie Baysox (6)

This was a much more interesting game, at least when compared to yesterday’s loss.  Vance Worley got the start and struggled through his 6.2 innings of work.  Worley clearly did not have his best stuff on the night.  He missed very few bats and seemed to be fighting his command all night long.  However, with that said, it was impressive to see Worley fight through a ballgame in which he was not at his best.  His final line was a respectable 6.2 innings pitched with 4 hits, 2 walks, 4 runs, 3 earned, 2 k’s, and 1 long ball.  It may have been a bit of good luck, but I like how he turned in a decent performance with less than stellar pitches.  Anyway, Overholt got blasted before German and Shortslef saved the day, combining to pitch 3.2 innings of scoreless ball.  Both German and Shortslef allowed 1 hit as they held down the Baysox until the 11th inning heroics of Michael D. Taylor.  Yes, Taylor broke out in a big way today, as he carried the Phils offense going 4-6 with 2 home runs, 3 RBI, and 3 runs scored including a walk off home run in the 11th inning.  Catcher Kevin Nelson also chipped in with a solo homer.  Sadly, the top of our lineup (Berry and Harman), went a combined 1-10.  But, this is not a game to end on a sad note, so lets imagine Taylor hitting walk off home runs in CBP.  I am happy already.

04/24/09 – Reading Phillies (2) vs. Bowie Baysox (1)

Back to normal for the Phils, as the pitching was front and center with the offense nothing but a distant afterthought.  Michael Stutes turned in a terrific performance, pitching 6 innings of 2 hit ball.  He also had an impressive 8 k’s to only 2 walks.  There is not much to say about a performance like this, as the numbers speak for themselves.  Very, very good start to both the game and season for Stutes.  German pitched another .2 innings of scoreless hitless ball before Escalona came on to collect a nerve wracking save.  Escalona allowed 2 hits, 1 walk, and 1 earned before finishing the game for the Phils with a 2-1 victory.  The offense collected some hits, but very few runs.  The Phils combined for 10 hits but only went 2-12 with RISP.  The offense was lead by Tuffy Gosewisch (2-4, 1 HR, 1 RBI, 1 R) and Ozzie Chavez (4-4).  Berry and Harman combined to go 1-8 with 5 k’s.  It is very hard to generate offense with those types of performances at the top.  Unfortunately, it seems to be a trend that will continue.

04/25/09 – Reading Phillies (5) vs. Bowie Baysox (3)

The return of Antonio Bastardo.  No, it is not a poorly made movie starring Antonio Banderas as some skirt-chasing home wrecker, although it could be.  Instead, we have our own Antonio returning to the Reading rotation for the first time this season.  Why have the Phils decided to switch Bastardo back into the rotation?  I have no idea.  They moved Bastardo to the ‘pen less than one month ago and he was adjusting to the change very well if his performances were any indication.  But, just like that he was switched back into the rotation.  Perhaps Taschner, Happ, Eyre, and Romero have satisfied the front office to the point where Bastardo has no chance of making a quick jump to the bigs as a LOOGY.  Anyway, Bastardo pitched brilliantly in his first start of the season, getting pulled after 5 innings of no-hit ball because of his pitch count.  Concepcion, who was removed from the rotation, along with Shortslef and Escalona all allowed 1 run each in their respective relief stints.  The offense was consistent, as Kevin Mahar and Carlos Leon were the only starters who did not collect at least one hit.  The star of the day was Mike Spidale, who went 4-4 with 3 RBI.  Spidale fell a home run short of the cycle.

04/26/09 – Reading Phillies (0) vs. Bowie Baysox (8)

The Phils went for the 4 game sweep of the Baysox and got rejected.  Brummett got the nod and was pounded for 12 hits in 5.1 innings of work.  He only managed to allow 3 earned runs, but it was still an awful performance.  For the offense, it did not get any better.  5 singles were hit by 5 different players to add up to a grand total of 0 runs.  I know I may be harping a bit at this point, but Berry and Harman went a combined 1-7 with 3 k’s.  Horrible.  Dreadful.  Depressing.  Nuff said…

04/28/09 – Reading Phillies (3) vs. Altoona Curve (1)

Earlier in the week, Savery pitched a mediocre game, had some bad luck, and took the loss.  This evening, Savery pitched a mediocre game, had some good luck, and won.  Yay!  Savery lasted 6 innings while allowing an alarming 10 base runners on 6 hits.  Fortunately, all of those base runners only amounted to 1 earned run.  Savery also had a less than impressive 1 strikeout.  Relieving Savery was German for the 7th and 8th innings and Zagirthski for the 9th inning save.  Each gave up two hits (German also allowed 2 BB) but neither allowed a run.  I guess the story of this game was the Curve going 0-10 with RISP.  The Phils took advantage of the good luck by virtue of the offense scraping out 3 runs on 6 hits.  It was an evenly distributed offensive output as Harman collected a RBI double and Taylor went 1-3 with a walk.  Not a whole lot of excitement with this Reading offense.

04/29/09 – Reading Phillies (2) vs. Altoona Curve (0)

In yesterday’s game, the Phils limited the Curve thanks to some good fortune.  In today’s game, the Phillies pitchers simply dominated their opponent with no luck needed.  Worley got the start and pitched an incredible 7 innings.  Worley allowed 1 hit through 6 innings, before allowing back-to-back singles to lead off the 7th.  Worley buckled down, however, and recorded 2 k’s in the final 3 outs of the inning.  Worley also walked 1 and struck out 7.  Terrific outing.  Once again, the Phillies offense were the beneficiaries of some strong pitching, as they only managed 2 runs but it was enough for the win.  Berry and Harman combined for their typical 1 hit to waste a great game by Taylor.  Taylor went 3-4 with a double and a run scored to pace the Phils’ offense.

04/30/09 – Reading Phillies (7) vs. Altoona Curve (12)

For the second straight series, the Phils enter the final game looking for a sweep, only to fall flat on their faces.  It figures that the one time the offense was cooking, the pitching would self destruct.  Stutes was the starter and got absolutely hammered with what was easily the worst pitching performance of his pro career.  Stutes only lasted 2 innings while surrendering 4 earned on 8 hits.  Of the relief pitchers, Concepcion and Overholt were similarly awful, allowing 4 and 3 earned runs respectively in their outings.  Shortslef, Sikaras, and Bisenius did have scoreless appearances.  Despite the pitching, the offense managed to tie their season high for runs scored with 7.  The top of the lineup (even Berry and Harman) did all of the damage with 5 of the top 6 hitters each collecting at least 2 hits.  Taylor was the true star, ending the game 3-5 with 2 runs, 2 doubles, 1 home run, and 5 RBI.  It certainly seems like Taylor has gotten his AA legs underneath of him.  He is the lone Phillies position prospect batting the way a lot of us expected.  Hopefully it continues.

05/01/09 – Reading Phillies (2) at Harrisburg Senators (4)

Antonio Bastardo got his second start on the season, and came back down to earth in a big way.  Bastardo lasted 4 innings while giving up 3 earned by way of 8 base runners, 6 on hits, 1 of which was a home run.  Bastardo also struck out 4.  Zagirthski made his second appearance, pitching another scoreless inning.  Following Zagirthski was the overnight sensation Matt German who sadly allowed his first earned run on the season.  German pitched 1.2 innings while allowing 2 hits and 2 walks.  The offense was not terrible as they collected 11 hits, they were just a terrible 3-10 with RISP.  Taylor broke his 7 game hit streak with an 0-4 performance.

05/02/09 – Reading Phillies (0) at Harrisburg Senators (3)

This was a rather long, slow, boring game.  Brummett got the start and didn’t exactly dazzle anyone.  He ended up lasting 5.2 innings and gave up 7 hits, 3 walks, and 2 earned runs.  He allowed a lot of base runners, but battled through many sloppy innings to only allow 2 earned (3 runs total).  Anderson and Shortslef both had scoreless appearances in relief of  Brummett.  The offense had a grand total of 4 hits, one each by Berry, Taylor, Gosewisch, and Chavez.  Umm, yeah, that is all.

05/03/09 – Reading Phillies (8) at Harrisburg Senators (4)

The Phils closed out both the Harrisburg series and the week on a positive note, as the offense took charge and carried the team to an 8-4 victory.  Savery was once again a disappointment as he allowed 7 hits and 2 walks in his 5 innings of work.  He gave up 4 earned while also striking out 4.  That was Savery’s third outing in this two week span, and each and every one of them have been a bit disappointing.  The bullpen did the job, as Overholt, German, and Escalona combined for 4 scoreless innings.  The real story of the day was the offense.  The Phils pounded out 13 hits in route to a season high 8 runs.  Every starting position player collected at least one hit, with the top five in the lineup all having 2 hits apiece.  Home runs were hit by Harman and Mahar.  Amazingly, the first four batters also all smacked 1 triple.  A real nice offensive effort to break out and steal one game against the Senators.

Prospect Watch

Brad Harman

Harman has had a pretty terrible season thus far.  There is really no way around that.  Since April 20th, Harman is batting .227 (10-44) with 5 R, 3 2B, 1 3B, 1 HR, 6 RBI, 5 BB, and 13 SO.  On the season, Harman has a stat line 0f .229/.297/.410.  Hmm, that looks incredibly similar to his 2008 season of .210/.280/.366.  His peripherals are also a near match between ’08 and ’09.  For example, ’08 BB% – 8.7 vs. ’09 BB% – 8.1 and ’08 K% – 27.9 vs. ’09 K% – 29.1.  Perhaps, a trend is starting to emerge which points anywhere but up.

Quintin Berry

So, in my opinion, Berry is much like Harman in the fact that I do not really think either of them are prospects at this point.  However, others still do and so I will highlight them here in the “prospect watch” section.  Also, how depressing would it be to have 1 hitting prospect on a AA roster?  Anyway, Berry’s stats over the past two weeks are not good, as one would expect, but glimmers of hope can be taken from a few choice statistics.  For the past two weeks Berry is batting .250 (10-40) with 8 R, 1 2B, 2 RBI, 5 BB, 8 SO, 4 SB, and 2 CS.  On the season Berry is now at .239/.351/.254.  I do not want to be too negative, so lets start with the positives.  Berry is adjusting to a new league and his average has climbed slightly over the past two weeks.  Also, Berry has continued to draw plenty of walks, as he now has 11 on the season compared to just 13 SO.  And the negatives.  His average may have climbed, but it only climbed to .239.  That is like bragging about being the smartest man in a room of Met’s fans.  Sure, you may be the smartest, but is it really an accomplishment?  Also, Berry, as has been customary throughout his career, is hitting with absolutely zero power.  His only extra-base hit on the season (82 PA) is a double.  Berry’s OBP and SLG have both dropped with every full minor league season: ’07 A – .393 OBP/.380 SLG, ’08 A+ – .362 OBP/.341 SLG, ’09 AA – .341 OBP/.254 SLG.  This is not a good sign for Berry’s prospect status.  Even Berry’s biggest strength, his speed and base running abilities have not shown through thus far at Reading, as he has been caught stealing twice in six attempts.  I could further harp on the negatives, but I think you get the picture.  Lets move on to a prospect who appears to have a slightly rosier future.

Michael Taylor

Over the past two weeks, the Eastern League has met the Michael Taylor of 2008.  Taylor has absolutely been on a tear after a somewhat slow start.  And by slow start I mean 9 games in which Taylor was facing AA competition for the first time in his career.  Anyway, Taylor hit .360 (18-50) with 12 R, 3 2B, 2 3B, 3 HR, 8 RBI, 2 BB, 6 SO, 2 SB, and 1 CS.  On the year, Taylor is now at .321/.365/.538.  Taylor is not drawing many walks with a 7.5 BB% in ’09.  However, he has also controlled the k’s with a 15.0 K%.  Taylor is the first Phillies position prospect to breakout and smack the ball around a little.  Let’s hope he continues to mash all year in Reading.

Antonio Bastardo

Bastardo had one relief appearance and two starts over the past two weeks.  I am not really sure why the Phillies have decided to yank Bastardo back and forth between the bullpen and starting rotation.  The original move to the bullpen made some sense, as Bastardo’s strengths and two pitch repertoire could be maximized by short relief appearances.  Also, it was possible that he could have been rushed to the majors in a LOOGY type of situation if Happ, Taschner, or Eyre disappeared from the bullpen for various reasons.  But, Bastardo is back and so that is where we stand.  His relief career ended with a 1.23 ERA, 0.95 WHIP, 1.70 FIP, 9.82 K/9, and 1.23 BB/9.  His career as a starter resumed with a dominating 5 inning outing.  Bastardo was taken out of the game with a perfect game intact as he hit his pitch count limit.  Bastardo’s next start wasn’t nearly as good.  In fact, Bastardo got smacked around for 3 earned runs scored by 8 base runners in 4 innings pitched.  All in all, Bastardo looked extremely good as a relief pitcher, so we will have to monitor how he adjusts back to life as a starter.

Tyson Brummett

Brummett had three starts on the week, and like the three bears, the first was good, the second was bad, and the third was right in the middle.  Combined, Brummett allowed 24 hits, 3 walks, and 6 earned in 18.2 innings.  On the season, Brummett now has a 3.14 ERA, 1.23 WHIP, 3.22 FIP, 4.9 BB%, and 13.0 K%.  When compared to his ’08 Reading stats of 7.28 ERA, 1.82 WHIP, 5.49 FIP, 12.0 BB%, and 12.3 K% a noticeable improvement is obvious.  Brummett has walked fewer batters in ’09 leading to most of the reduction in his WHIP.  It isn’t a great start for Brummett, but certainly counts as improvement.

Sergio Escalona

Escalona, to his credit, has pitched better than I expected.  Serving as Reading’s closer, Escalona has racked up 7 saves on the season.  In the last two weeks, he has made 6 appearances and has allowed 6 H, 2 BB, and 2 ER while striking out 4 in 6.2 innings of work.  Escalona is sporting a fairly shiny 2.92 ERA on the year.  His peripherals are not as good.  A 1.41 WHIP and a 4.71 FIP for 2009 may be an indicator that trouble lies ahead.  Also, he does not have a great K% at only 15.6%.  He is on the 40 man roster, left handed, and 24 years old.  It is time for him to giddy-up or giddy-out. 

Edgar Garcia

Garcia is still in visa purgatory.

Joe Savery

As I have said before, Savery made three bad to mediocre performances on the week.  His totals for those 3 outings are 17 IP, 18 H, 9 ER, 8 BB, and 11 SO.  His season ERA of 4.33 is not great, but could be worst.  That is all I am gonna say about Joe for the time being, as I am planning a more extensive write-up on him in next week’s Reading Weekly Report.  Stay tuned.

Michael Stutes

We saw the best of Michael Stutes this week and the worst of Michael Stutes this week.  The yin and the yang, or something like that.  Stutes’ first start was a dominating 6 innings of scoreless ball.  His second outing was a disastrous 2 innings of 4 earned runs.  On the season, Stutes has had 3 good outings and now the one bad one.  Overall he has a 3.32 ERA and a 2.96 FIP.  So, Stutes has still been exceptional on the whole.  We will just have to wait and see where his season goes as we do not really have any other professional season for comparisons.  His next start is May 5th.

Vance Worley

Worley has been the most consistent of the Phillies’ starters, as he has yet to have a truly poor outing.  Worley had two outings and combined to pitch 13.2 innings of 7 hit 3 walk ball.  He gave up a total of 3 runs and also struck out 9.  On the season, Worley has a 2.22 ERA.  He has an exceptional WHIP of 0.93, which has been helped by an unsustainable .219 BABIP.  So, his FIP of 3.27 does not echo is pristine ERA, but it is still very good.  Similar to Stutes, Worley does not really have any comparison seasons, so we just have to see where this goes.  He dominated lesser competition last year and has thus far performed well at a level more in line with his age and experience.

Michael Zagurski

Or should I say Zagirthski?  Anyway, Zagurski made his first two appearances for Reading since tommy john surgery and his comeback has thus far been a success.  In 2 IP Zagurski has allowed 2 hits.  Yup, that is it.  No walks, runs, or k’s.  Simple.  Sweet.  Short.  Perhaps Zagurski and Escalona are the reason that Bastardo fines himself back in the rotation.  Both are lefty relievers who in reality have no shot of ever starting in the bigs.  Maybe this “surplus” pushed Bastardo back into the rotation with the hope of him developing that third pitch.  Anyway, even though Zagurski has big league experience do not expect to see him in Philadelphia any time soon.  The Philadelphia Phillies bullpen is pretty well stocked, plus there are several relievers with big league experience performing very well in AAA.  Perhaps a quick promotion to AAA will be in order.

Stat Leaders

Michael Taylor – R – T-7th – 14

Michael Taylor – H – T-8th – 25

Michael Taylor – HR – T-8th – 3

Michael Taylor – RBI – T-12th – 14

Michael Taylor – TB – T-4th – 42

Michael Taylor – SLG – 5th – .538

Michael Taylor – AVG – T-10th – .321

Michael Taylor – OPS – 11th – .903

Brad Harman – SO – T-4th – 26

Vance Worley – ERA – 10th – 2.22

Vance Worley – WHIP – T-5th – 0.95

Sergio Escalona – SV – 3rd – 7

Transactions

04/21/09 – Reading Phillies placed OF Gus Milner on the 7-Day disabled list retroactive to April 20, 2009.  Left oblique strain.

04/25/09 – LHP Michael Zagurski assigned to Reading Phillies from Clearwater Threshers.

04/28/09 – Carlos Ruiz assigned to Reading Phillies from Philadelphia Phillies.

04/30/09 – C Carlos Ruiz assigned to Lehigh Valley IronPigs from Reading Phillies.

05/01/09 – RHP Jason Anderson assigned to Reading Phillies from Lehigh Valley IronPigs.

05/03/09 – Reading Phillies activated OF Gus Milner from the 7-Day disabled list.

05/03/09 – Reading Phillies placed RHP Joe Bisenius on the 7-Day disabled list.  Turf toe in right foot.

53 thoughts on “Reading Phillies Weekly Report (4/20 – 5/3)

  1. Great write-up. Imagine how good that team will be with Drabek and Dom Brown later this season.

    Like

  2. Great job as always….I really cant understand the flip flop on Bastardo, especially with the number of seemingly “legit” starting prospects.

    Like

  3. very good detail and props for analyzing a prospect’s performance without passion, which is how it should be analyzed.

    question on savery – did you see a gun on him? any feedback on the secondary pitches? the knock on him last year that was most concerning was his stuff was poor and his speed was below 90. we can deal with poor stats for now as long as he is developing something. disregarding stats, do you see anything of value coming from him now? or is that in the write-up?

    Like

  4. i thought the phillies said they wanted to give bastardo more innings to refine his secondary stuff.

    Like

  5. I am really looking forward to see how Stutes rebounds. If he responds well I will be much more optimistic about him(I am already pretty optimistic).

    Also did someone say he was touching 96 a couple of weeks ago? I’m probably remembering that wrong but if he gets up in to the 96-97 range he could become an elite prospect.

    Like

  6. Thanks, Neduolcaz. Exceptional journaling. You gave us all much sought after detail.

    Note: I’ve heard the radar gun in Reading is “fast”, so beware of reading too much into Stutes’ velocity. And on the flip side, if Savery is still producing “slow” radar readings, that’s even more of a concern. I’ll be interested in reading your write-up of Mr. Savery.

    Like

  7. “Ryanhoward06 Says:
    May 3, 2009 at 10:24 pm
    I am really looking forward to see how Stutes rebounds.
    Also did someone say he was touching 96 a couple of weeks ago?”

    Sometimes the paper will read 92-94 mph, other occasions its been 91-92 mph.

    Like

  8. The highest I have seen Stutes hit is 95, and that is with the stadium’s radar gun. Savery has touched 92. Stutes typically sits 90-92 while Savery is around 89-91.

    Like

  9. Really enjoyed watching Michael Taylor play baseball over the weekend. He made that triple into the gap in right center look easy as he slid into third yesterday. His defense is amazing. He almost has too much arm strength as he air mailed a throw from the right field bullpen over the head of the shortstop covering second on a double down the line and threw a one hop strike to the plate on a fly ball which the runner on third wisely chose not to challenge his arm. On another play he saved a run by charging a line drive which he trapped in right holding the runner at third.

    Interesting the note the the hitting of three Phils corner outfield prospects in their last ten games. With Lehigh Valley John Mayberry Jr. hit .350 with 4 homers; with Reading Michael Taylor hit .395 with 3 homers and Dominic Brown with Clearwater hit .368 with 3 homers.

    Like

  10. So Reading’s offense consists of “Michael Taylor and hopefully a good pitching performance.” Taylor has been hot, and I’m hoping to get to see a Reading game in the next few weeks, since I’ll be out of commission for the summer (knee replacement 2.5 on June 1 8^( ).

    Savery’s lackluster performance is starting to concern me. He should be performing better than he is. He hasn’t been bad – but he hasn’t been pitching the way a first rounder should be.

    – Jeff

    Like

  11. I just wonder about Savery when he was drafted, I thought he was a easy sign, that’s why he was drafted. First round potential who had no where to go. hated the pick then and hate it now. How many pitchers out of rice never make it or are always hurt. It’s to me is like the Stanford swing,You know that to me was the draft where I wonder there commitment to the draft, as I have stated before ,because potello was still there and he is already at a young age in the majors for detroit. But maybe they are getting it after last draft where they went after some hard to sign players and got them like Cosart, and a couple others. I hope they leave Taylor in reading for the year and not rush him, Same with brown.

    Like

  12. **Savery’s lackluster performance is starting to concern me. He should be performing better than he is. He hasn’t been bad – but he hasn’t been pitching the way a first rounder should be.**

    this was my point when i argued he should start the season in clearwater. let him get some wins under his belt and groove his mechanics. i really think that they hurt him by moving him up before his performance indicated he was ready. i know they like to “callenge” players by moving them up before they dominate a level. but i don’t agree with the move for savery.

    Like

  13. Mikemike, Porcello was passed over by 26 other teams as well. If a team wants to avoid breaking the bank for a high school pitcher, I’ll never complain. 70-80% of the time it’s a bust.

    Like

  14. So Drabek put up another good start, when does he move up? And what will his innings total be for the year?

    Like

  15. Alan you know a lot more than me about how many would make it or not’ But Porcello was passed over by a lot of small market teams. and he wanted his money. The phillies taking savery just bother me he was out of rice, got hurt and didn’t dazzle the scouts with his stuff. and at that time I Really believe they knew he would sign for slot or lower, because he had no other options, unless he wanted to go to a independent league,

    Like

  16. It’s amazing what Taylor is doing already in Reading without any real protection in the lineup. Sorry, guys like Mahar and Nelson and Spidale are not going to strike fear into the opposing pitchers.

    If we could get a few more legitimate hitting prospects up there at some point this year, I think he could do even better.

    Like

  17. I do not believe protection really exists at the major league level, let alone in the minors where winning has nothing to do with being successful. If an opposing pitching prospect were facing Taylor, what incentive would he have to pitch around him? It is about learning, not winning. With that said, Taylor has certainly been impressive, and will hopefully continue to get better no matter who is promoted from Clearwater.

    Like

  18. I’m with you Zac – I would even say that there is probably more incentive for a pitching prospect to go after a team’s big hitter rather than pitching around him.

    – Jeff

    Like

  19. Peripheral statistics are just sometimes a good indicator. For example, here are their minor league BB & K numbers:

    Youkilis: 324 BB, 211 K
    Donald: 134 BB, 237 K

    Just a SLIGHT difference there, eh?

    Like

  20. I know it’s very easy to say now but the Phillies could have had Michael Stanton, Freddie Freeman, Kellen Kulbacki(I like him), Jordan Zimmerman or Chris Withrow(one spot below Savery). All were signed for less then what Savery got.

    I think Savery is a good guy and I am really pulling for him but I don’t see how he can be successful in the majors.

    Depending on his performance this year, I think they might have to consider moving him to the bullpen(maybe later this year) or make him an hitter.

    Like

  21. ryanhoward06 doesn’t him coming out of rice scare scouts, all I ever heard is the coach at Rice ruins pitchers. or am I mistaken

    Like

  22. Mikemike- In the 2007 BA draft database writeup on Savery it mentions that many scouts have that concern with Rice pitchers.

    They also said that he might be a steal in the second half of the first round.

    Like

  23. If I’m allowed to I will post the entire pre-draft writeup.

    I’m not sure if I am allowed to post subscription content on this site.

    Like

  24. Decisions will have to be made this season about the top three lefty starters in the system, Bastardo, Savery and Flande. Which of them are major league starting prospects? All are about the same age within about 4 months of each other.

    Over the weekend I was able to watch Bastardo and Savery pitch and hope to see Flande sometime this year. Bastardo seems to have more of an upside than Savery but the Front Office seems torn as to whether he is a starter or reliever. Savery on the other hand was used as a pinch hitter in Friday’s game so they must decide if he can pitch in the major leagues or let him become a position player.

    I was not able to see the R-Phils speed gun from my seat behind home plate on Friday . The pitch speed is not listed on the outfield board in Harrisburg as it is in Reading. The movement on Bastardo’s one type of fastball reminded me of a “riser” that I used to face in fast pitch softball. His pitch seemed to jump with a lot of late movement as it approached the plate. Savery on the other hand needed to keep his pitches down at the knees or he was hit hard on Sunday.

    With a better seat yesterday I was able to see the speed gun held by Mike Stutes register 91 for the only time in the third inning as Savery had to get his velocity up with the bases loaded. That inning Savery did strike out a Senator lefthanded power hitter after almost giving up a grand slam to him on a pitch that was hit just foul out of the park down the right field line. Then he threw him a 91 MPH fast ball out of zone and came back to get him on a swinging strike out with a nice 75 mph change up. Most of the time though Savery would open an inning with a 87 mph fastball and then get it up to 89 later in the inning mixing in his change up and a low 80’s breaking ball.

    Like

  25. RickeyBranch was it you or someone else who said stutes was at 97 one game and people question the radar gun at reading, People said it was fast, iF that is true what is Savery fastball top out at, if he is mostly 89 and the gun is fast,

    Like

  26. I believe Rickey is referring to the gun the team uses to chart pitches and not the “official” stadium gun to excite fans. Hopefully at least.

    Like

  27. mikemike —
    Drafting outside the primo part of the first round, the Phillies tried to keep getting primo talent by drafting guys with some health or makeup questions. There was Hamels’ broken arm, Drabek’s character and the guys in later rounds like Howard and Donald and Taylor who had bad college careers or bad college senior years after being ace prospects out of HS. Savery continued this gambling trend. He was expected to be an early first round pick based on his HS and early success at Rice. Then the injury and the loss of velocity. The Phillies likely bet that the injury was not all that serious and we could reclaim the Savery of the early Rice days. This time we seem to have lost the bet, but the overall strategy has been so successful it is hard to question. There is also the Ankiel fallback to cushion the loss.

    Like

  28. I agree, allentown- I think the phillies have had a pretty solid philosophy regarding high-risk “tainted” talent. There are no sure superstars after #15 in the draft– so they either have to suck and get a good draft slot or have to compensate somehow. Drafting Savery was in no way the Phillies playing it safe- and I liked the choice when they made it. I mean, he hasn’t been terrible or anything… I think people just have a negative view on him. For instance, in Caz’s report- Joe’s 6 inning, 6 strikeout 4 run start was “mediocre” and “Frustrating,” whereas Worley’s 6 inning, 4 run 1 strikeout game the next night was “respectable.” I think people just have unrealistic expectations because he was a first round draft pick.

    That being said I like the phils “tainted” talent draft philosophy, and I hope Colby Shreve becomes the next good player to come out of it.

    Like

  29. Joe doesn’t look like he’ll ever be the dominant guy we hoped he’d be, granted it’s early but it’s been more than a year now and if he came out lighting the world on fire we’d be a bit more optimistic. His numbers just look okay and according to first hand report he’s been very hittable. At this point, I think we have to hope he becomes a serviceable 5 or bullpen guy.

    Like

  30. ***I think people just have a negative view on him. For instance, in Caz’s report- Joe’s 6 inning, 6 strikeout 4 run start was “mediocre” and “Frustrating,” whereas Worley’s 6 inning, 4 run 1 strikeout game the next night was “respectable.” I think people just have unrealistic expectations because he was a first round draft pick. ***

    you must be kidding with this. i mean, did you really look at the stats?

    in the games you reference:
    – worley pitched was 6.2 innings vs. 6 for savery
    – worley gave up 3 ER vs. 4 for savery
    – worley had a sub 1 whip, where savery’s was over 1

    that is a much better game for worley

    overall:
    – worley is also throwing 93 vs. savery’s 89.
    – worley has been noted as having good 2ndary pitches vs. savery’s which have not been noted as quality yet.
    – worley has given up 6 er vs. savery’s 13
    – worley has a whip of 0.96 vs. 1.44

    that is not an issue with expectations. it is an issue with performance. it is also an issue with not being ready for a level.

    Like

  31. Sampson getting hit a little again. BUTTTT Great peripherals and FINALLY SOME K’s!

    Like

  32. Shunky I Disagree with you about no superstars after 15 that to me is such a blanket remarks, How do you know if the draft is strong , if teams won’t pay there demand and they drop. A lot of team don’t want anything to do with boras clients. second there is no way Savery with a injury history, a senior, Had any bargaining power. But I was so in love with Porcello and he is a starter allready, but I just hate to miss on first rounders. But I realize that , nomatter how good you draft will miss more than times then hit.

    Like

  33. mikemike, I think it is a bit unfair to continue to criticize the Phillies for not selecting Rick Porcello. It is not as if he would have signed for the same price as Savery. With that in mind, the Phillies did not miss on Porcello or think he would not turn out to be a good pitcher. They simply felt he was asking for more money than they were willing to spend. And, if that is the case (which it clearly was), then it would have been a wasted pick. The Phils would not have had any first round talent coming into the system that year and would have had to wait an additional year. Plus, with that theoretical compensatory pick, the Phils would have had no leverage and would have been forced to take a slot sign anyway. It just does not add up. Every team except for one passed on Porcello, the Phils were not alone.

    Like

  34. I agree with Mikemike on the sure fire superstar issue. There might not be a sure fire superstars but many of the leagues top players have come from late rounds. Just look at last years MVP voting of players that went in the draft.

    Pujols- 13th round
    Howard- 5th round
    Then Berkman, Wright, and Sabathia were in the back end of the first round.

    Now Chipper, Utley(15th) and others went early.

    That’s what I love about the MLB draft. I wouldn’t mind writing something for this site on the Phillies possibilities this year and the draft on the whole. 🙂

    Like

  35. Ryanhoward06. Hope you do it, now all I really hear is Strasberg, Gibson talk. would love to know if it is a weak or strong draft. If it has a strong college or high school class and to me how is the infield prospects, can we get some infield help in this draft? I believe we don’t have a first, and if someone can talk about the international players would be great. That’s if its allright with PPand the rest of the posters.
    ]
    s

    Like

  36. Sid –

    I’m not certain, but I think that Taylor may not play every day because he has diabetes. From what I understand, he just needs a rest occasionally.

    Like

  37. I have type one diabetes myself. It’s a pain in the ass but as long as you properly monitor your blood sugar, it causes no serious problems. Ron Santo had it and played 164 games one season. I doubt it will be a serious impediment on Taylor, particularly since he appears to be in fine shape.

    Like

  38. I have diabetes too and happen to big an strong like MT
    (COUGH)(cant see me can you)
    All kidding aside sometimes you just have to rest sometimes
    15 minutes on my back does the trick. I would believe having the best doctors and diet would enable young men to play almost everyday(it worked for Bobby Clark too)
    Anyway when he is a star in Philly someone can name a veggieburger after him ,a big viggieburger
    Another nice game by Worley and Z.
    Berry needs to pick it up,Now

    Like

  39. Anyone else get excited when they saw the name “Otero” in the Reading box score as a reliever for Connecticut?

    Like

  40. i am most inter in r.branchs comment that m.taylor is the best 5 tool player hes seen since guerrero any more info rb. and depending on his age it seems worley is a legitimate threat to move up.any info.

    Like

  41. Savery seemed stronger in his early short starts . Of cource it was against weaker teams. Maybe in relief he may gain speed
    signed
    StillHoping

    Like

Comments are closed.