And the Phillies take….

We’ll keep the regular discussion in the long draft post, but I’ll update this one as well with our selections, along with scouting reports where applicable.

24. Anthony Hewitt, SS (Salisbury School, CT)

Hewitt is the epitome of high-risk, high-reward. The risk starts with his signability: Any team that drafts Hewitt must be prepared to open its wallet and buy the academic-minded Brooklyn native-turned-Connecticut boarding school star out of a commitment to Vanderbilt. There’s also a huge risk that he simply won’t hit in professional ball: his raw bat was overmatched against quality pitching on the showcase circuit last summer, and though he dominated vastly inferior prep competition this spring, he still struggles to recognize breaking balls and can get locked up at times by ordinary fastballs. But then he’ll crush a ball 450 feet and give scouts a glimpse of his prodigious upside. Several scouts said he was second to Tim Beckham as the best athlete at the East Coast showcase last summer, and he has three legitimate above-average tools in his raw power, speed and arm strength. His muscular 6-foot-1, 190-pound frame evokes Ron Gant, and his work ethic and charisma stand out. Hewitt plays shortstop for Salisbury, but his poor footwork, stiff actions and lack of instincts will dictate a shift to third base or more likely the outfield, where he has enough speed and arm strength for center or right. Hewitt has generated mountains of buzz in the Northeast and could sneak into the supplemental round or even the back of the first round if a club falls in love with his potential enough to overlook his crudeness.

Check below for the rest of the picks…

34. Zach Collier, OF (Chino Hills HS, CA)

Collier was not selected to participate in the 2007 Area Code Games or the Aflac Classic, but he’s had a high profile nonetheless. He started to generate buzz during the local Connie Mack summer season as a teammate of Isaac Galloway and Aaron Hicks. Rave reviews from parents and youth coaches began to filter down to scouts, and Collier helped his cause with strong showings in two showcase events held at the MLB Urban Youth Academy in Compton. He continued gaining ground this spring, and then moved into first-round consideration when he took a Hicks 93 mph fastball deep during a tournament game in Fullerton. To make sure the 40-plus scouts in attendance were paying attention, Collier ripped two more hits. Lefthanded all the way, Collier has an athletic and projectable 6-foot-2, 195-pound outfielder’s frame. His above-average speed makes him a threat as a baserunner and permits him to patrol center field for now. As he slows down and matures physically, he’ll play an outfield corner, and his average arm makes right field a possibility. Collier had a surgical procedure to improve blood flow to his heart, performed in May 2006, which may be a concern for some clubs, but he’s been medically cleared for two years and has had no problems. Collier’s hitting ability and solid all-around game had him moving up boards, possibly in the middle of the first round.

51. Anthony Gose, LHP/OF

Gose has perhaps the strongest left arm of any Southern California high school pitching prospect since Bill Bordley, a first-round pick in the mid 1970s. However, his small stature and a recent bout of rotator cuff tendinitis have his draft status in doubt. Gose’s blistering fastball ranges from 92-96 mph, peaking at 97. Both his frame and four-seam fastball draw legitimate comparisons to both Scott Kazmir and Billy Wagner. In professional baseball, Gose will need to improve and sharpen both his 77 mph curve and 75 mph changeup. Gose profiles as a lefthanded closer or set-up man, since he loses significant velocity as a game progresses. He’ll also need to clean up his mechanics and learn to slow down his frantic pace. Scouts are currently awaiting results on another MRI of Gose’s shoulder; one in mid-April showed no fracture or labrum tear. After starting several games early in the season, Gose was restricted to DH duty for much of the spring. As with so many young hurlers, high pitch counts and year-round play add to injury concerns with Gose. When he’s healthy or when he’s not pitching, Gose plays center field, with plus-plus speed and arm being his best tools. He’s aggressive on the bases with a knack for stealing bags, taking the extra base, and flying into bases with a head-first slide. However, Gose has never consistently shown enough hitting ability to convince scouts he can hit professional pitching. Severe doubts about his bat make it most likely that Gose will be drafted and signed as a pitcher.

71. Jason Knapp, RHP (North Hunterdon HS, NJ)

There is no scouting consensus on righthander Jason Knapp. Some scouts believe he’s the top prospect in the Garden State, destined to throw 100 mph in the big leagues, while other scouts see nothing more than arm strength—and one even called him “the most overrated guy in New Jersey.” Late in the spring, Knapp was pitching at 94-96 mph in short relief outings, and he could add velocity thanks to his loose arm and projectable 6-foot-5 frame, which started to shed some baby fat this spring. But the rest of Knapp’s stuff needs work, as so does his delivery. He tries to throw a three-quarters curveball from a lower arm slot that might be better suited for a slider, but the pitch shows decent depth from time to time. His changeup is also a work in progress but has good arm speed and fade. Knapp has fundamental flaws in his delivery, yet for all that, he could go in the top three rounds—or even rocket into the first round—if a club falls in love with his upside. Like Quinton Miller, he’s committed to North Carolina but is considered an easier sign.

102. Vance Worley, RHP (Long Beach State)

At 6-foot-2, 200 pounds, Worley has a big body and big arm that attracted attention last summer in the Cape Cod League. He wasn’t able to carry that success over this spring for the Dirtbags, but teams that saw him good last summer have seen flashes of that this spring. Worley’s four-seam fastball sits in the 91-92 mph range, peaking at 93-94. He has struggled at times with his 87-88 mph two-seamer, which gets hammered when left up in the zone. Both fastballs show armside movement, and he will cut the four-seamer at times. Worley mixes in a changeup and curveball. Both need development, and he will drop his arm slot and slow down his arm when delivering the change. Command is the primary concern with Worley, not in terms of walks but in quality of pitches and efficiency, as he frequently finds himself in deep counts. With refinement of his secondary offerings, he could develop into a mid-rotation starter in pro ball, but his power arm makes a conversion to the bullpen a solid option.

109. Jonathon Pettibone, RHP (Esperanza HS, CA)

I have nothing on him

136. Trevor May, RHP (Kelso HS, WA)

While righthander Trevor May is the top prospect in the state, the bulk of the top players in Washington were position players. May stood out from the crowd for showing a three-pitch mix and solid velocity. He got scouts excited by flashing 92 mph early (with some reports of 94), then settled into the 87-90 range more consistently, and in general was better early in the season. His curveball was his best pitch and could be above-average in the future as he adds power. He has a feel for throwing it for strikes or burying it as a chase pitch. May’s arm works well, though he has some maintenance in his delivery, making it difficult for him to repeat. He’s rangy and has decent athletic ability. He was asking for first-five-rounds money to keep him from going to Washington, and a team that got him crosschecked on a good day could take him as high as the third round.

166. Jeremy Hamilton, 1B (Wright State)

Hamilton is one of the best pure hitters in the 2008 draft. The Horizon League player of the year, he ended the regular season batting .413/.516/.738 with more walks (36) than strikeouts (25). He excels at driving balls to the opposite-field gap in left-center. Though he hit .209 as a reserve with Team USA last summer, there’s little worry about his ability to hit with wood bats. The concern is whether he’ll hit for the power teams want in a first baseman, as he’s not very big (6-foot-1, 185 pounds) and doesn’t pull many pitches. Hamilton is more in the Mark Grace mold, including the Gold Glove potential. His hands are soft and he may be the best defensive first baseman in the draft. Hamilton lacks the speed and athleticism to play the outfield at the pro level, though that was his primary position with the U.S. national team.

196. Colby Schreve, RHP (CC of Southern Nevada)

CCSN’s Colby Shreve, an unsigned eighth-round pick last year of the Braves, was in the running to be the top juco prospect in the country this spring, reaching 94 mph consistently and showing a solid-average slider. Shreve’s mechanics left something to be desired for some scouts, so they weren’t surprised when he went down at midseason with an elbow injury. He wound up having Tommy John surgery, and while he has an Arkansas commitment, many expect Shreve to sign and still get a six-figure signing bonus despite the surgery—much as Nick Adenhart did with the Angels in 2004.

23 thoughts on “And the Phillies take….

  1. Well, when it comes down to it, they’re all crapshoots. We just happen to have the crapshoot that has more potential or more crap than others.

    Like

  2. Same old Phillies. No wonder they have a problem developing pitchers. They take 17-year-old “toolsies” rather than available quality pitchers.

    Like

  3. Well so far they are going after possible hard to sign guys, hopefully they open the wallet and dont let these guys slip into college.

    Like

  4. WOW how often does a team draft a player twice? Worley was drafted by us in the 20th round a few years ago, I THINK!

    Like

  5. Wow, Hewitty, Collier and Knapp. I hope you’ve kept the shotgun in storage…

    Like

  6. very disapointing 1st two picks, they sound like the kid jackson from chicago a few years ago, jeff jackson. what was the problem with christian friedrich?

    Like

  7. Just got our replacement for Howard when we trade him LOL but someone who can actually play D

    Like

  8. Christian Friedrich is good with no upside ceiling.

    He projects as a #3 or #4 Starter, not too enthralling for any First Round Pick.

    Like

  9. I’ll take a guy labeled as a “potential superstar” over a guy who is labeled a “potential middle of the rotation starter” or “potential closer or relief pitcher”. To me the selection of Hewitt, Collier, and Gose (assuming he was drafted as a position player) shows that the Phillies didn’t really have confidence as to which one was going to develop, so if they hit .333 then one of the three would work out. Still, I like both the Hewitt and Collier picks, and I like even more that we got Knapp with our 4th pick when there was speculation that we may take him with our 1st pick.

    Like

  10. this quote on the sign-ability of hewitt on phillies.com

    “I don’t want to drag out the process too long,” Hewitt said. “I’m pretty sure [the talks] will go pretty well. I really want to go ahead and pursue my professional career as soon as possible. I’m eager to start.”

    Like

  11. Doesn’t take much perception to see that PG has assessed the big club, the prospects on the pharm, and has decided to leave the team with longer-term developing prospects rather than fixes for “soon.”

    The major players on the big club are nearing 30 which usually is the age when talent and experience come together and the game becomes easier only to the extent that you’ve learned what is going on.

    The nearest guys to come up SOON are outfielders, catchers, and pitchers who will be able to supply themselves to the bigs since Vic, Pat, Jenkins, Werth are unknowns as to their time in Philly.

    Also, it seems that PG is going for hard throiwing righties of HS age as well as a few college guys!

    Like it all…for continuing competitiveness for more years…

    Like

  12. Information I have found on Pettibone…

    The 6-foot-5, 195-pound right-hander is committed to USC. Went 8-2 with a 2.88 ERA, and earned Orange County Register All-Sunset League first-team honors. Is the son of pitcher Jay Pettibone, who made a handful of major league appearances with the Minnesota Twins in 1983.

    Jonathan Pettibone, a right-handed pitcher from Esperanza, has been selected by the Philadelphia Phillies — who appear to have taken a shine to Southland prospects — with the 110th pick overall Thursday, in Compensation Round B of the Major League Baseball first-year player draft. The Phillies had a pick in this round because they failed to sign Tommy Toledo, their third-round pick in last year’s draft. Tommy Toledo? Really? (Obviously, it was not Tommy Toledo)

    The Phillies received compensation for not signing last year’s third-rounder, right-hander Brandon Workman. Said area scout Darrell Conner of Pettitbone: “Long, lean athlete who will fill out and get stronger. Projectible high school pitcher. Played basketball. Can be back end of the rotation starter. Father, Jay, pitched for the Twins (1983).”

    Also, Pettibone apparently lead his league in strikeouts. I do not know if this is correct, but that is all I have found.

    Like

  13. I attend the Canyon Church in Anaheim Hills, CA with Jonathan Pettibone. Real good kid, has hid head on straight, the son of a former pitcher. Won’t have attitude or behavior troubles. High 80’s fastball, but can reach the 90’s. Was to go to USC, but opted to sign with the Phillies.

    Like

  14. >>Hey Joel, thanks for the info. Do you know for a fact that Jonathan has signed already?
    I am not sure, but it was announced to the congregation that he was going to sign, and that he’d be leaving for Clearwater, FL this week. He says he’s ready. I know his daddy ain’t ready.
    I think his daddy (like I would be) was hoping for at least one
    season at SC, just to have him close to home a little while longer.

    Like

Comments are closed.